You won your club tournament. Congratulations and handshakes follow. In your head, a voice says: “They played badly this weekend. Next week they will see my real level.” You represent your club in a regional competition: “If only they knew how much I struggled with basic positions this week.” You analyse a position well and a strong player nods: “They are just being polite.”
These examples illustrate doubt. Clance and Imes (1978) describe the impostor phenomenon in high-achieving women; that does not demonstrate a particular intensity in chess. This article concerns the general experience. For fear of losing a newly reached rating, see the article about the 2000-Elo milestone.
How impostor feelings can work
One way to examine these feelings is through asymmetric attribution. Successes may be assigned to external, unstable factors: luck, weak opponents or an unusually good day. Failures may be assigned to internal, stable factors: lack of talent or “real” incompetence supposedly present all along.
That pattern can produce a distorted account: signs of competence go into the “unreliable external factors” column, while mistakes go into “permanent internal factors”. It can repeatedly lead back to “I am not really good”. This is a framework for reflection, not a mechanism diagnosed in every reader.
Bravata and colleagues’ review (2020) shows that frequency estimates vary greatly by population, scale and cutoff. It does not establish that 60–70% of chess players experience the phenomenon. The suggestions below are not treatments demonstrated effective in this game.
Chess situations that may amplify doubt
Some chess situations may feed these feelings. The following are possible applications of the psychological framework, not findings from an experimental comparison between activities.
Errors that can be examined
Recorded games preserve moves. An engine or opponent can help identify an error, which may make the mistake feel particularly visible. Not every game is public or recorded, and no engine evaluation measures your whole competence.
Analysis can identify an error and suggest work. It does not establish general incompetence. An engine score concerns a decision in a position, not your legitimacy as a participant.
A community with visible comparisons
Public ratings and tournament results make some performance comparisons easy. You can see other players’ ratings and recent results, which may direct attention towards those stronger than you.
That can become part of your experience of doubt, but comparison is not identical for everyone and a public number does not dictate what you must think about yourself.
The depth of the knowledge involved
There are always positions and themes you handle less well. Gaps do not follow uniform Elo thresholds: a player may know certain endgames well yet mishandle a familiar opening. Describing the gap precisely helps more than concluding “I do not deserve my rating”.
Possible behaviours to observe
The following behaviours can provide questions for reflection. None establishes a diagnosis by itself.
Repeated negative accounts after wins. Consistently minimising your own contribution: “I was lucky”, “They were out of form”, “Their opening was terrible”.
Treating losses as normal and wins as abnormal. If you expect to lose to everyone and every win surprises you, examine that asymmetry rather than assuming it proves your true level.
Preparation used to manage fear. Spending many hours memorising lines may be about learning, trying to control a situation or avoiding exposure. The time spent alone does not establish the function.
Rejecting compliments. “You played that move well!” may receive “I did not really know why I played it; I was lucky.” Ask whether you can also recognise a specific good decision without treating every modest response as evidence of a problem.
Avoiding situations where your level might be exposed. Declining tournaments or stronger opponents may sometimes relate to fear, but can also reflect other preferences or constraints.
Who experiences it at different playing strengths?
The studies reviewed by Bravata and colleagues concern several populations. They do not show that the strongest players are necessarily most affected. No anonymous testimony is used here as evidence of prevalence in the elite.
A persistent fear of exposure also differs from temporary disappointment or recognition of a technical weakness. You can describe your experience without labelling yourself from one poor game.
Distinguishing impostor feelings from a realistic assessment
How do you distinguish these feelings from an honest assessment of your limits?
One question is whether your account recognises strengths as well as weaknesses and changes with evidence. If wins are always minimised and losses amplified, that pattern deserves examination. It is not a self-diagnostic test, and one response does not determine a psychological category.
Your rating provides information about results within a particular system. It measures neither your personal worth nor all your skills. Its fluctuations are discussed in the milestone article.
Approaches to try
These are suggestions for reflection to adapt, without a promise that doubt will disappear.
Keep a record of competence. After a game or session, record what you did well in specific terms: “I correctly evaluated the endgame pawn structure”, or “I found the tactical line on move 23 under time pressure”. This creates examples to compare with your account. Working through a collection of tactical exercises can provide additional concrete tasks; solving one problem still does not measure your entire ability.
Examine what contributed to a win. Identify specific decisions: managing time or recognising a positional structure, for example. Check those explanations against the game rather than merely replacing every external explanation with a flattering internal one.
Return at a manageable difficulty. Choose a playing situation you want to regain and progress gradually, without forcing a confrontation that overwhelms you.
Seek precise feedback. Ask a coach or stronger player for an honest, structured assessment. Concrete variations and identified strengths or weaknesses let you compare your beliefs with something more specific than reassurance alone.
After reading: after three games, try identifying one decision within your control for each win: time use, a plan or a tactic, rather than only “I was lucky”. Treat this as an exercise, not a compulsory test.
If doubt causes lasting distress or stops you playing as you wish, you can discuss it with a professional. A coach’s observations and a game journal do not replace appropriate support.
An annotated position is better evidence than a compliment
Imagine a player who has just been invited to a stronger training group. Someone says, “You belong here.” The player replies, “You haven't seen my last game.” Both statements are hard to test. Try getting specific. On move twenty-three of that game, the player saw a threat down the open file and spent two minutes comparing a king move with a rook exchange. One idea failed in a variation they missed; their chosen move nevertheless dealt with the immediate danger. Now ask two separate questions. Was the reply good? And which part of the reasoning could this player repeat in another game? The engine can help investigate the first. To address the second, put a similar decision on a fresh board and let them explain it.
It would be easy to replace the harsh judgement with an equally global reassurance: “You spotted the threat, so you're obviously a great defender.” A single example cannot bear that claim either. A better reply is modest enough to believe: “In this position you found the open file before I pointed it out. In the next one let's check which rook should contest it.” If the player is unsure of their place, an invitation to work on a particular problem may feel more credible than a title that they are expected to accept.
Give luck its correct share of the win
Consider a game won when the opponent disconnects in a level ending. It is reasonable to say that the final result says little about your ability to win that ending. Consider another game where the opponent misses a defence because your series of threats made the right reply difficult to find. That result contains both a mistake by the opponent and a sequence of decisions by you. If every opponent's error is classified as luck and every one of your errors as proof of incompetence, the accounting system has made a fair verdict impossible before you begin. Take one win and one loss and ask of both: what did I control, what did my opponent control, and where is the evidence inconclusive?
For a concrete record, keep one variation from each game in the same format. Someone who wins through a blunder can still show the position that created the threat. Someone who loses after playing well can still name the defence they missed. Over time the entries will include both familiar mistakes and decisions you can now explain clearly. When a stronger player offers a seat at the analysis board, you will have a question ready that does not depend on announcing your rating or defending your right to be in the room.
That last distinction matters to organisers too. If a new member hesitates to join, explain what participation involves. “We're analysing the final round. You can show one move or just listen” communicates more than “This group is for good players.” The first invitation allows someone to contribute while uncertain of their level. It does not require guessing what is going on in their head, and it extends the same courtesy to a genuinely inexperienced visitor. The aim is to make the next action possible, whatever the cause of the hesitation.
Sources
- Clance, P. R., & Imes, S. A. (1978). The Impostor Phenomenon in High Achieving Women: Dynamics and Therapeutic Intervention. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research & Practice, 15(3), 241–247. Full article.
- Bravata, D. M., et al. (2020). Prevalence, Predictors, and Treatment of Impostor Syndrome: a Systematic Review. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 35, 1252–1275. Review.
Comments